If you’re shopping for a sub-compact tractor, two names rise to the top of nearly every shortlist: the Massey Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX (most shoppers compare against the BX23S). Both are trusted by small farms, landscapers, and acreage owners who want tractor power in a compact, easy-to-maneuver footprint. But which one is the smarter buy for your work?
In this in-depth review, we compare performance, hydraulics, loader/backhoe capability, mowing, ergonomics, stability, cost of ownership, dealer network, resale value, price, and best-use applications. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of where each machine shines.
Ready to check pricing on the Massey model? Look at our Massey Ferguson GC1720 for sale and ask about attachments and financing.
Quick Snapshot: Where Each Tractor Tends to Win
Choose the Massey Ferguson GC1720 if you want:
- Strong loader performance and confident digging with base backhoe packages
- Value-oriented bundling — many dealers offer loader-backhoe package configurations
- Smooth, low-maintenance operation
Choose the Kubota BX (e.g., BX23S) if you want:
- The most comprehensive dealer support and parts availability in most regions
- Deep North American presence and a large owner community
- Excellent fit/finish and an extensive OEM accessory ecosystem
Both tractors are great. Your best choice really comes down to how — and how often — you’ll use it.
Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX Quick Comparison
| Feature | Massey Ferguson GC1720 | Kubota BX23S |
|---|---|---|
| Engine Power | 22.5 HP diesel | 21.6–23 HP diesel |
| Transmission | Hydrostatic | Hydrostatic |
| Best For | Loader, backhoe, property work | Lawn care, property maintenance, resale value |
| Strength | Value-focused packages | Dealer network and aftermarket support |
| Consideration | Smaller dealer network in some regions | Higher purchase price in many configurations |
Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX Core Specs at a Glance
| Category | Massey Ferguson GC1720 | Kubota BX23S (representative BX) |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | ~22.5 HP diesel | ~23 HP diesel |
| Transmission | Hydrostatic (2-range) | Hydrostatic (2-range) |
| Loader Lift | Comparable for the class — actual capacity depends on loader model, bucket, ballast, and measurement method | |
| Backhoe Dig Depth | ~6.5 ft class | ~6.1 ft class |
| 3-Point Hitch | Category 1 | Category 1 |
| Typical Package | Usually sold with loader + backhoe | Loader/backhoe widely available, often priced separately |
Specifics vary by model year, configuration, and bucket size — always confirm with official materials or your dealer. For manufacturer information, see the Massey Ferguson sub-compact tractor lineup and the Kubota USA BX Series.
Engine & Transmission: Real-World Feel Matters
On paper, power ratings are close — both are low-20s HP diesels with hydrostatic two-range transmissions. In use, what matters is throttle response, hydro pedal feedback, and how well each tractor maintains power under a full loader bucket or while digging.
- GC1720: Smooth, torquey feel at working RPMs. The hydro pedal is easy for new operators to modulate, helping with precise loader placement and back-dragging.
- BX Series: A narrow edge in rated horsepower on some models, with hydro controls many operators like. Kubota’s pedal feel is predictable and smooth.
Verdict: Tie. Both are well-tuned diesel/hydrostatic pairs for sub-compact use — the difference is subtle and often comes down to feel in a demo.
Hydraulics & PTO: Powering the Work
Loader speed, backhoe reaction, and 3-point implement lift all depend on hydraulic flow and pressure. Both machines offer ample capacity for the attachments most sub-compact owners run.
- GC1720: Owners praise smooth loader operation and a responsive backhoe, especially through the dig/roll cycle.
- BX Series: Smooth, predictable performance with a reputation for long-wearing hydraulic components.
Verdict: Slight edge to the GC1720 if a “planted” feel during heavy loader/backhoe cycles matters most to you.
Loader Performance: Daily Productivity
Most sub-compact owners use the loader on nearly every start, so lifting confidence and stability are top priorities.
Both tractors offer comparable loader performance for their class. Actual lift capacity depends on the specific loader model (e.g., FL1805 vs. LA340), the bucket, ballast, and the measurement point (pivot pin vs. bucket center) — so published numbers aren’t always directly comparable across brands.
- GC1720: Many owners report confident lift and stability with proper ballast, particularly for gravel, soil, mulch, and firewood work.
- BX Series: A durable workhorse loader with a strong aftermarket accessory ecosystem (tooth bars, quick-attach, etc.). Lift ratings vary with bucket and geometry.
Verdict: Close enough that the right call comes down to a demo on your own ground with the specific loader and bucket configuration you’re considering.
Backhoe Capability: Depth of Dig & Control
Backhoes are a major reason buyers choose sub-compacts over lawn/garden tractors.
Both tractors provide similar digging capability for irrigation, drainage, landscaping, and light excavation. The GC1720 may offer a slight advantage in dig depth depending on the specific backhoe package and model year, but published specs are close enough that this shouldn’t be a deciding factor on its own.
- GC1720: Often quoted in the ≈6.5 ft class, with planted footing and straightforward controls.
- BX Series: Well-supported backhoe configurations (≈6.1 ft) — more than sufficient for irrigation, drains, and planting holes.
Verdict: Roughly comparable. The GC1720 is also commonly available through many dealers as a bundled loader-backhoe package, which is worth weighing alongside raw dig-depth numbers.
Mowing & Grounds Care: Cut Quality + Comfort
Add a mid-mount mower (MMM) and either machine becomes a capable acreage mower.
- GC1720: Clean cut with sharp blades; anti-scalp wheels and height control give a tidy finish on uneven terrain.
- BX Series: Kubota decks are well-regarded, with owners consistently praising cut quality and deck durability.
Verdict: Tie. Choose deck width (typically 54–60″ in this class) based on gates, trees, and trailer capacity, and keep blades sharp on either platform.
Ergonomics, Controls & Visibility
Seat time adds up — pedal layout, joystick location, visibility to the bucket edge, and backhoe seat comfort all matter.
- GC1720: Easy controls with excellent visibility to loader corners. The backhoe station is frequently praised for comfort.
- BX Series: A well-tuned operator station; Kubota is known for consistent control placement across models.
Verdict: Tie, with a slight edge to the GC1720 for loader/backhoe task orientation.
Dimensions, Stability & Tires
Sub-compacts win on maneuverability, but loaded stability builds operator confidence.
- GC1720: Stands “planted” with proper ballast when carrying a bucket load; the operating position helps new operators feel at ease.
- BX Series: Extremely maneuverable; owners often add rear ballast or a box blade for loader stability — a good practice on either tractor.
Verdict: Tie, though the GC1720 can be slightly more stable under heavy front loads when well-ballasted.
Attachments & Ecosystem
Your tractor is a tool carrier — the more attachments available, the more work it can do.
- GC1720: A well-rounded lineup — loader, backhoe, MMM, snow blower/blades, rotary tiller, post hole digger, box blade, forks, sprayers, spreaders, rakes, and more. Many buyers appreciate value-priced loader+backhoe bundles.
- BX Series: An enormous ecosystem — Kubota’s dealer base and accessory marketplace offer wide OEM and aftermarket availability.
Verdict: Tie on breadth. The GC1720 generally wins on bundle value; the BX Series wins on variety of accessories available through dealers.
Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX Price, Value & Resale
Street prices vary by region, condition, and what’s bundled together. Rather than quote a fixed “new” price that can go stale or mismatch current inventory, here’s the general pattern:
- GC1720: Often positioned as the stronger upfront value, especially when bundled with loader + backhoe.
- Kubota BX: Loader and backhoe are frequently priced separately, which can raise the total compared to a bundled GC1720 package.
- Used market: Both hold value well. Kubota sometimes commands a slightly higher resale premium due to brand recognition, but a GC1720 sold with loader/backhoe closes that gap quickly.
Contact us for current pricing on either platform based on available inventory and configuration.
Verdict: GC1720 for upfront bundled value; Kubota BX for resale strength tied to brand recognition and dealer density.
Maintenance & Ownership Experience
Both are straightforward to maintain: check fluids, grease loader/backhoe pins and PTO shafts, keep blades sharp, inspect hoses, and store under cover.
- GC1720: Logical access points; owners like the clean, serviceable design.
- BX Series: Kubota’s construction and parts inventory make maintenance easy through a wide dealer network.
Verdict: Tie. Both are simple to maintain, with parts readily available.
Dealer Network & Support
Dealer strength is regional. In general:
- Kubota BX: Broader U.S. dealer network, fast parts turnaround, and a large owner community.
- Massey Ferguson (GC series): A stable, well-established ag brand with solid dealers, though availability can vary more by region.
Verdict: Kubota BX if dealer proximity is your top priority. If you have a good relationship with a local Massey dealer, the GC1720 is a very compelling choice.
Real-World Scenarios: Which Tractor Is Right for You?
1) Gravel & Material Handling Every Week
Routine loader operation (soil/stone/mulch), re-crowning driveways, palleting. Choice: GC1720 if you prioritize loader convenience and package value; Kubota BX if you’d rather have dealer-backed aftermarket loader accessories nearby.
2) Trenching, Planting, and Light Excavation
Irrigation lines, French drains, tree holes, stump cleanup. Choice: GC1720 for a slight edge in dig depth and backhoe ergonomics; Kubota BX if dig depth in the ≈6.1 ft range covers your typical jobs and dealer support matters more.
3) Lawn + Light Chores + Winter Clearing
60″ deck mowing, seasonal mulching, occasional trenching, snow clearing. Choice: Tie. Dealer convenience favors the BX; package value (deck+loader+backhoe) favors the GC1720.
4) Contractor/Landscaper, Multi-Job Types
Small backyards, frequent hauling, lots of implement swaps. Choice: Tie. Go with the platform your local, most responsive dealer supports best.
Ground Clearance & Working on Rough Terrain
Both tractors provide adequate ground clearance for mowing, landscaping, and light agricultural work. If you’ll frequently operate on uneven ground, wooded trails, or rough pasture, compare tire options, skid protection, and implement clearance in addition to horsepower when making your final decision.
Warranty Considerations
Warranty coverage varies by country, dealer, and current promotional offers. Before purchasing, confirm engine, powertrain, and implement warranty terms directly with your dealer, since terms can change year to year.
Who Should Buy the GC1720?
Ideal for:
- Properties in the 2–15 acre range
- Hobby farms
- Horse properties
- Landscapers
- Homeowners with regular property maintenance needs
- Snow removal duty
Who Should Buy the Kubota BX?
Ideal for:
- Buyers with a nearby Kubota dealer
- Those prioritizing long-term resale value
- Heavy, frequent mower use
- Owners who already have Kubota-compatible attachments
Attachment Pricing
Attachment pricing varies by manufacturer, configuration, dealer, and whether purchased individually or as part of a bundled package. Contact Farmers Equipment for current pricing and bundle availability on loaders, backhoes, mowers, snow blowers, and more.
Tip: Bundling tractor + attachments together can often reduce total cost, simplify financing, and improve resale value later.
Not sure which tractor fits your needs? Check out our Massey Ferguson tractors for sale.
Safety & Best Practices
Regardless of brand, loader/backhoe use demands sound practice:
- Ballast properly for loader use; keep the bucket low during transport
- Ride with ROPS and seatbelts engaged; watch slopes and soft shoulders
- Keep PTO guards in place and shear bolts/pins on hand
- Grease pivot points and service hydraulics on schedule
Also consider the Massey Ferguson GC1725M, a slightly updated GC-series option worth comparing if you’re still deciding on the right model. For a deeper dive, see our GC1720 Attachments Guide and our GC1720 Buyer’s Guide.
Frequently Asked Questions Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX
Q1: Which one burns less fuel?
Both are economical diesels. In real-world use, the difference is minimal — work style and load matter more than the brand.
Q2: Does the GC1720 really lift more with the loader?
In most applications, owners report stronger practical lift at the pile when properly ballasted, though exact numbers vary — confirm specs with your dealer.
Q3: Which digs deeper?
The GC1720 backhoe is typically quoted around 6.5 ft, compared to about 6.1 ft for comparable BX configurations. Depth varies by bucket and model year — check official documentation.
Q4: Which holds value better?
Kubota generally enjoys a slight resale premium due to brand recognition, but a GC1720 sold with loader/backhoe closes that gap quickly.
Q5: Which suits a first-time buyer?
Both are beginner-friendly thanks to hydrostatic transmissions. Many newcomers like the GC1720’s sightlines to the bucket lip and backhoe comfort; Kubota’s controls are also intuitive.
Q6: Which one has more attachments?
Both support the core implements — loader, backhoe, MMM, blower/blades, tiller, post hole digger, box blade, forks, and more. Kubota’s dealer network offers broader accessory availability; Massey’s bundle value is the stronger draw.
Q7: Can I finance attachments with the tractor?
Yes — most buyers bundle tractor and implements together for better financing terms and a single payment. Ask us about seasonal programs.
Q8: Is the Massey Ferguson GC1720 better than the Kubota BX23S?
The better choice depends on your priorities. The GC1720 is attractive for buyers wanting loader-backhoe versatility and package value, while the Kubota BX23S is known for dealer availability, resale value, and accessory support.
Q9: Is the Massey Ferguson GC1720 discontinued?
Model availability changes over time and varies by region and dealer. Contact us to confirm current availability of new or used GC1720 units.
Q10: What’s the difference between the GC1720 and the GC1725M?
The GC1725M is a newer generation in the GC-series lineup, generally offering updated features and slightly different specs compared to the original GC1720. See our GC1725M listing for current specs and availability.
Other Compact Tractor Resources
Bottom Line: Which Tractor Takes It?
If you regularly haul materials and perform light excavation work, the Massey Ferguson GC1720 is a strong option thanks to its compact size, available loader-backhoe configurations, and versatility across property maintenance tasks.
If your top priority is dealer proximity, long-term resale value, and access to the largest parts and accessory network, the Kubota BX (like the BX23S) is the stronger fit. You may pay a bit more on some configurations, but support and parts availability are widespread.
Choice: GC1720 if you prioritize loader/backhoe versatility and package value. Choose the Kubota BX if dealer availability, resale value, and accessory support are your highest priorities.
Ask about current offers or request a bundle quote: Massey Ferguson GC1720 for sale.