If you’re shopping for a sub-compact tractor, two names rise to the top of nearly every shortlist: the Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX (most shoppers compare against the BX23S). Both are trusted by small farms, landscapers, and acreage owners who want tractor power in a compact, easy-to-maneuver footprint. But which one is the smarter buy for your work?
Here in this in-depth review, we compare performance, hydraulics, loader/backhoe capability, mowing prowess, ergonomics, stability, cost of ownership, dealer network, resale value, price, and best-use applications. By the end of it, you’ll have a good idea of where each machine shines and where one will find a spot in your garage.
Ready to guess the price of the Massey model? Look at our Massey Ferguson GC1720 for sale
and ask about attachments/financing.
Quick Snapshot: Where Each Tractor Tends to Win
Choose the Massey Ferguson GC1720 if you want:
Strenuous loader performance and confident digging with the base backhoe packages that most customers want.
Value-oriented package (loader + backhoe usually matched).
Smooth, low-maintenance operation.
Choose the Kubota BX (e.g., BX23S) if you want:
Most comprehensive dealer support and parts availability in most regions.
Deep experience in North America and massive owner population.
Excellent fit/finish and extensive OEM accessory ecosystem.
Both of the tractors are great. Your best choice is really a function of how you’ll be using and what you’ll be using most.
Core Specs (At-a-Glance)
Category\tMassey Ferguson GC1720\tKubota BX23S (representative BX)
Engine\t~22.5 HP diesel\t~23 HP diesel
Transmission\tHydrostatic (2-range)\tHydrostatic (2-range)
Loader Lift\t≈ higher working edge (usually ~800–870 lb class)\t≈ competitive but usually lower than GC1720 Backhoe Dig Depth\t≈ 6.5 ft class\t≈ 6.1 ft class
3-Point Hitch\tCategory 1\tCategory 1
Typical Package\tUsually sold with loader + backhoe\tLoader/backhoe widely available; often priced separately
*Specifics vary by model year, configuration, bucket size, and configuration. Always refer to official materials or your dealer. For manufacturer information see Massey Ferguson GC1700 Series and Kubota USA BX Series.
Both tractors are respected leaders in the sub-compact class. See full model details on the Massey Ferguson GC1700 Series and the Kubota BX Series at Kubota USA.
Engine & Transmission: Real-World Feel Matters
On paper, power ratings are even (low-20s HP diesel with hydrostatic two-range transmissions). In use, what operators see is smooth throttle response, predictable hydro pedal feedback, and how nicely the tractor maintains power when the loader bucket is full or when digging.
GC1720: Awarded for a smooth, torquey sensation at working RPMs. The hydro pedal is easy for new operators to modulate and helps with precise loader placement and back-dragging.
BX Series: Narrow edge in rated horsepower depending on the specific model, with hydro controls many operators like. Kubota’s pedal feel is predictable and smooth.
Verdict: Tie. They’re both diesel/hydrostatic pairs tuned for sub-compact applications. The difference is subtle and comes down to your own feeling in a demo.
Hydraulics & PTO: Powering the Work
Loader speed, backhoe reaction, and 3-pt implement lift are powered by hydraulic flow and pressure. Both machines provide ample hydraulic capacity for the attachments most sub-compact owners use.
GC1720: Owners praise smooth loader operation and responsive backhoe, especially in dig/roll cycle.
BX Series: Smooth, predictable performance and a long-wearing hydraulic component reputation.
Verdict: Tie with Massey on practical grounds if heavy loader/backhoe work cycles and insistence on that “planted” feel when curling up and lifting heavy buckets are of primary importance to you.
Loader Performance: Daily Productivity
Sub-compactors are worked with the loader by most owners on every start. That makes lifting confidence and stability major priorities.
GC1720: Buyers will typically price quote it for stronger real-world lift and stability when bucket loads get heavy (with proper ballast).
BX Series: Durable workhorse loader with great aftermarket accessories (tooth bars, quick-attach, etc.). Lift ratings vary with bucket and geometry.
Verdict: Massey GC1720 wins the edge for loader applications, especially if you move gravel, soil, mulch, or firewood frequently and want that extra confidence at the pile.
Backhoe Capability: Depth of Dig & Control
Backhoes are a principal explanation for why there are so many buyers who prefer sub-compacts to lawn/garden tractors.
GC1720: Typically recognized as deeper-digging in its class (≈6.5 ft) with planted footing and straightforward control ergonomics.
BX Series: Very popular, well-supported backhoe configurations (≈6.1 ft). More than sufficient for irrigation, drains, and planting holes.
Verdict: Massey GC1720 by a nose for dig depth and bucket control feel. If trenching/planting is a weekly task, you’ll appreciate the extra reach.
The Massey Ferguson GC1720 tractor often includes loader and backhoe, giving it more value.
Mowing & Grounds Care: Cut Quality + Comfort
Add a mid-mount mower (MMM) and either machine becomes a serious acreage mower.
GC1720: Clean cut with blades kept sharp; anti-scalp wheels and height control offer a tidy finish across uneven areas.
BX Series: Kubota decks are wonderful; owners generally rave about cut quality and deck durability.
Verdict: Tie. Choose deck width (typically 54–60″ in this class) based on gates, trees, and trailer capacity. Keep blades sharp and clean deck on either platform.
Ferguson GC1720 vs Kubota BX Ergonomics, Controls & Visibility
Seat time can add up. Pedal layout, joystick location, visibility to bucket edge, and backhoe seat comfort are factors.
GC1720: Easy controls and excellent visibility to loader corners. Backhoe station ergonomics frequently praised.
BX Series: Smoothly tuned operator station; Kubota is known for consistent control location model-to-model.
Verdict: Tie, but with edge to comfort/visibility for GC1720 for loader/backhoe task orientation.
Dimensions, Stability & Tires
Sub-compacts win maneuverability, but loaded stability is the confidence builder.
GC1720: Stands “planted” with proper ballast when traveling with a bucket load; operating position and steering arrangement allows new operators to feel at ease.
BX Series: Extremely maneuverable; owners will ballast the rear or install a box blade to provide stability for loader work great practice on either tractor.
Verdict: Tie, although Massey can be slightly more stable under heavy front loads if well-ballasted.
Attachments & Ecosystem
Your tractor is a tool carrier. The more attachments you have to choose from, the more you can work.
GC1720: Well-rounded lineup of practical products loader, backhoe, MMM, snow blower/blades, rotary tiller, post hole digger, box blade, forks, sprayers, spreaders, rakes, etc. Some buyers like that GC1720 packages are value-priced with loader+backhoe included in the package.
BX Series: Enormous ecosystem; Kubota’s dealer base and accessory marketplace are enormous, with OEM and aftermarket availability for nearly anything.
Verdict: Tie on breadth. On bundle value, the GC1720 generally gets it; on variety of accessories available through dealers, BX is ahead.
GC1720 vs Kubota BX23S Price, Value & Resale
Street prices are regional, condition, and what’s being bundled together.
New GC1720 (average): Generally $6,000–$12,000 range with loader + backhoe depending on year/config.
New Kubota BX (average): Generally $9,000–$15,000 with loader/backhoe separately priced in most quotes.
Used market: Both hold value equally; Kubota at times brings slightly more resale, and a GC1720 sold with loader/backhoe closes the gap very rapidly.
Verdict: Massey GC1720 for upfront value (especially bundled). Kubota BX for resale weight due to brand name/concentration of dealers. Either model, bundles with standard attachments (loader/backhoe/MMM) resell better.
Maintenance & Ownership Experience
Both are simple to maintain: check fluids, grease loader/backhoe pins and PTO shafts, keep blades sharp, check hoses, and store under cover.
GC1720: Access points are logical; owners like the clean, serviceable design.
BX Series: Kubota construction and parts inventory ensure easy maintenance through many dealers.
Verdict: Tie. Simple to maintain and parts are available for both.
Dealer Network & Support
Dealer strength is regional. In general:
Kubota BX: Broader U.S. dealer network, rapid parts turnaround, and enormous owners group.
Massey Ferguson (GC series): Stable, well-established ag brand with solid dealers; availability can be more inconsistent by region.
Verdict: Kubota BX if dealer proximity is your #1 issue. If you like the Massey dealer you’re working with, the GC1720 is a very compelling choice.
Real-World Scenarios: Which Tractor Is Right for You?
1) Gravel & Material Handling Every Week
Routine loader operation (soil/stone/mulch), re-crowning driveways, palleting.
Choice: GC1720 for loader convenience and planted feel, with box blade/land plane.
2) Trenching, Planting, and Light Excavation
Irrigation line, french drains, tree holes, stump cleanup.
Choice: GC1720 for deeper dig and smooth backhoe ergonomics.
3) Lawn + Light Chores + Winter Clearing
60″ deck mowing, seasonal mulching, occasional trench, snow clearing.
Pick: Tie. If dealer convenience matters, BX. If package value (deck+loader+BH) matters, GC1720 can be more aggressive on price.
4) Contractor/Landscaper, Multi-Job Types
Small backyards, lots of hauling around, lots of swaps.
Pick: Tie. Choose the platform your local, most responsive dealer excels at.
Attachment Prices (Both Platforms, Typical Prices)
Loader: $2,500–$3,000
Backhoe: $3,000–$8,000
Mid-Mount Mower: $1,000–$2,500
Snow Blower: $2,500–$2,500
Rotary Tiller: $1,500–$2,000
Post Hole Digger: $800–$1,500
Box Blade / Land Plane: $400–$1,000
Tip: Bundle tractor + attachments to conserve (often 10–15%), simplify financing, and improve resale later.
check out out tractors for sale
Safety & Best Practices
Regardless of brand, loader/backhoe use demands sound practice:
Ballast in proper way for loader use; keep bucket low during transport.
Ride with ROPS and seatbelts; observe slopes and soft shoulders.
Keep PTO guards and keep shear bolts/pins handy.
Grease pivot points and service hydraulics regularly.
see more 2021 Massey Ferguson gc1725m for sale
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Which one burns less fuel?
Both are economical diesels. In real-world use, the difference is minimal; work style and load more so. Owners typically find the GC1720 to be sipping fuel under constant workloads.
Q2: Does the GC1720 really lift more with the loader?
In most applications, owners find the GC1720 has a stronger practical lift at the pile when ballasted. Numbers vary check specs with your dealer.
Q3: Which goes deeper?
The GC1720 backhoe is usually quoted at ≈6.5 ft compared to ≈6.1 ft for comparable BX configurations. Depths vary with bucket and model year; use official documents.
Q4: Which holds value better?
Kubota generally enjoys a resale premium due to prevalence of the brand, but a GC1720 with loader/backhoe enjoys strong resale and bridges the gap.
Q5: Which suits the first-time buyer?
Both are beginner-friendly with hydrostatic transmissions. The majority of newbies like the GC1720’s sightlines to the bucket lip and backhoe comfort; Kubota’s controls are intuitive also.
Q6: Which one has more attachments?
Both fit the necessary implements: loader, backhoe, MMM, blower/blades, tiller, PHD, box blade, forks, etc. Kubota’s dealer network offers wide accessory availability; Massey’s bundle value is compelling.
Q7: Can I finance attachments using the tractor?
Yes most consumers bundle to save and pay once. Call us on seasonal programs.
Bottom Line: Which Tractor Takes It?
If you’re in the habit of hauling materials and digging on a weekly basis, and want top value in a package deal, the Massey Ferguson GC1720 is a tough choice to beat secure loader feel, modestly higher digging, and excellent daily ergonomics.
If your number one priority is proximity to dealers and access to the largest parts and owner support network, a Kubota BX (like the BX23S) is the ticket. You’ll pay a bit more in some models, but support and parts are widespread.
We believe the GC1720 is the most bang-for-buck choice for most small farms and acreage owners in this battle especially when you factor in a loader + backhoe package.
Look for existing offers or request bundle quotation: Purchase Massey Ferguson GC1720 for sale.